by Dr Asif Channer in The Nation, Dec 26, 2023
The unfolding drama in Balochistan, Pakistan’s largest province, unveils a nuanced narrative marked by historical grievances, contemporary protests, and the ongoing struggle for autonomy. The roots of dissent trace back to the early 1970s when the Baloch Students Organisation-Awami (BSO-Awami) emerged from a split with the Baloch Students Organisation (BSO). With a Marxist-Leninist ideology, BSO-Awami vehemently opposed the sardari system and aligned itself with the Baluch People’s Liberation Front in resisting Pakistani control.
Taj Baloch, the inaugural chairman of BSO-Awami, paved the way for a legacy of resistance. His successor, Abdul Nabi Bangulzai, took up the mantle as a guerrilla leader, emphasising the organisation’s commitment to challenging the status quo. Tragically, Mulla Baksh Dasthi, the third chairman, faced a grim fate at the hands of unknown gunmen in 2011, underscoring the risks associated with advocating for change in Balochistan.
Fast-forward to December 24, 2023, when Islamabad became the stage for Baloch protestors airing their grievances. Responding to the unrest, caretaker Prime Minister Anwaar-ul-Haq Kakar initiated talks through a committee featuring influential figures like Minister for Information and Broadcasting Murtaza Solangi, caretaker Federal Minister for Privatisation Fawad Hassan Fawad, and Governor Balochistan Malki Wali Kakar. However, this effort to engage in dialogue was swiftly overshadowed by the heavy-handed tactics employed by Islamabad Police, leading to the detainment of several protestors amid the use of water cannons and baton charges.
The ensuing crackdown triggered condemnation from human rights organisations and analysts, thrusting Balochistan onto the global stage. In response, the Baloch Yekjehti Committee (BYC) sought legal recourse by filing a petition in the Islamabad High Court. Chief Justice Aamer Farooq’s stern warning to Islamabad IG Akbar Nasir Khan underscored the constitutional right of Balochis to peaceful demonstration, injecting a legal dimension into the unfolding narrative. The committee’s subsequent talks with the families of the detained protestors resulted in their immediate release. In a press conference, committee members justified the use of force, framing it as a preventive measure to avert potential catastrophe. This episode encapsulates the delicate balance authorities must strike between maintaining order and respecting citizens’ rights, a conundrum emblematic of the broader challenges faced in Balochistan. Beyond the immediate events lies a deeper struggle. Enforced disappearances, a recurring issue in Balochistan, draw attention both domestically and internationally. The Baloch people’s quest for justice and autonomy within the Pakistani state remains a central theme, with each protest and crackdown contributing to the evolving narrative.
Media coverage, both local and international, plays a pivotal role in shaping perceptions and influencing policy. The delicate dance between reporting facts and potentially swaying public opinion further complicates an already intricate situation. As the world watches, the narrative of Balochistan’s struggle for autonomy is shaped not only by the events themselves but also by the lens through which they are presented. In the midst of this complexity, the call for inclusive dialogue emerges as a crucial step toward resolution. Balancing the aspirations of the Baloch people with the responsibilities of the state necessitates a nuanced and empathetic approach. The committee’s commitment to ongoing negotiations signals a willingness to address the concerns raised by protestors and work toward a mutually beneficial outcome.
Balochistan finds itself at a crossroads, where historical echoes reverberate in the struggles of today. The recent events, from protests to legal interventions and committee talks, provide a snapshot of the multifaceted challenges faced by the people of Balochistan. As the world watches and policymakers deliberate, the path forward must navigate the complexities of identity, autonomy, and the delicate dance between authority and dissent. Balochistan’s journey toward a harmonious resolution remains a dynamic and evolving narrative, with each chapter revealing new facets of a region caught between its past and its aspirations for the future.
https://www.nation.com.pk/26-Dec-2023/turbulence-in-balochistan
